Jump to content


Photo

Alternative Lists


  • Please log in to reply
7 replies to this topic

#1 JRGoldman

JRGoldman
  • Members
  • 163 posts
  • Gender:Male
  • Location:Philadelphia, PA

Posted 13 May 2016 - 02:16 PM

So throughout the process, Grimmas has stated he would be open to publishing results using different voting critera. I know a lot of people have come up with suggestions and interesting spins, but they are seemingly scattered throughout the different threads I thought it might be nice to have a centralized thread. 

 

My suggestion would be to see what the overall top 100 would look like if only votes for people's top 10 counted, like the actual Sight&Sound poll. 

 

I would also ask that Grimmas has already shot down any sort of "PWO Posters Only" list, so it's probably safe not to request something like that, considering that conversation has already happened and doesn't need to be rehashed. 

 

 



#2 TravJ1979

TravJ1979
  • Members
  • 1309 posts
  • Gender:Male
  • Location:Indiana

Posted 13 May 2016 - 03:21 PM

I'd like to see a list ranked by Average Vote.  I think Flair would still be number one as he is the only wrestler to get a single-digit average vote, but It'd still be interesting to see.



#3 TravJ1979

TravJ1979
  • Members
  • 1309 posts
  • Gender:Male
  • Location:Indiana

Posted 13 May 2016 - 03:38 PM

I went ahead and Excel-magic'd what this would look like.  (Ran it so that wrestler had to appear on at least 50 ballots.  This eliminated High averages of very low number of ballots)

 

NEW RANK >> ORIGINAL RANK >> WRESTLER >> AVG >> # BALLOTS

 

1 >> 1) Ric Flair   >> 7.95 >> 148
2 >> 4) Mitsuharu Misawa   >> 10.23 >> 137
3 >> 3) Stan Hansen   >> 11.06 >> 143
4 >> 2) Terry Funk   >> 11.36 >> 148
5 >> 9) Toshiaki Kawada   >> 13.19 >> 129
6 >> 8) Kenta Kobashi   >> 16.62 >> 135
7 >> 13) Genichiro Tenryu   >> 17.51 >> 131
8 >> 5) Daniel Bryan   >> 17.63 >> 142
9 >> 6) Jushin Liger   >> 18.03 >> 145
10 >> 10) Jerry Lawler   >> 18.76 >> 136
11 >> 22) Negro Casas   >> 19.03 >> 108
12 >> 11) Jumbo Tsuruta   >> 19.29 >> 135
13 >> 7) Rey Mysterio Jr.   >> 20.92 >> 146
14 >> 16) Nick Bockwinkel   >> 21.41 >> 132
15 >> 29) El Hijo del Santo   >> 22.52 >> 95
16 >> 12) Eddie Guerrero   >> 24.16 >> 146
17 >> 15) Ricky Steamboat   >> 24.64 >> 144
18 >> 23) Shinya Hashimoto   >> 25.45 >> 119
19 >> 20) Tatsumi Fujinami   >> 25.94 >> 124
20 >> 17) Bret Hart   >> 26.14 >> 138
21 >> 14) Vader   >> 26.24 >> 148
22 >> 18) Randy Savage   >> 26.46 >> 138
23 >> 37) El Satanico   >> 29.73 >> 83
24 >> 62) Kiyoshi Tamura   >> 31.11 >> 55
25 >> 40) Yoshiaki Fujiawara   >> 32.64 >> 81
26 >> 34) Chris Benoit   >> 32.88 >> 93
27 >> 21) William Regal   >> 33.01 >> 138
28 >> 27) Jun Akiyama   >> 33.97 >> 114
29 >> 36) Buddy Rose   >> 34.66 >> 92
30 >> 35) El Dandy   >> 34.7 >> 96
31 >> 19) Arn Anderson   >> 35.49 >> 144
32 >> 26) Akira Taue   >> 36.16 >> 121
33 >> 56) Jim Breaks   >> 36.28 >> 67
34 >> 24) Steve Austin   >> 37.02 >> 139
35 >> 52) Akira Hokuto   >> 37.45 >> 76
36 >> 31) Shawn Michaels   >> 38.11 >> 111
37 >> 25) Barry Windham   >> 39.56 >> 130
38 >> 49) Aja Kong   >> 39.89 >> 83
39 >> 70) Yuki Ishikawa   >> 40.22 >> 54
40 >> 28) Bobby Eaton   >> 41.39 >> 128
41 >> 30) John Cena   >> 41.7 >> 126
42 >> 41) Riki Choshu   >> 42.79 >> 97
43 >> 45) Harley Race   >> 43.78 >> 93
44 >> 33) Ricky Morton   >> 43.99 >> 116
45 >> 60) Volk Han   >> 44.6 >> 68
46 >> 50) Billy Robinson   >> 45.37 >> 91
47 >> 32) Dustin Rhodes   >> 45.69 >> 124
48 >> 61) Bull Nakano   >> 46.81 >> 72
49 >> 43) Rick Martel   >> 46.82 >> 104
50 >> 39) AJ Styles   >> 48.2 >> 109
51 >> 67) Jack Brisco   >> 48.28 >> 65
52 >> 68) Kurt Angle   >> 48.36 >> 64
53 >> 69) Blue Panther   >> 48.77 >> 65
54 >> 53) Dick Murdoch   >> 49.03 >> 92
55 >> 48) Fit Finlay   >> 49.3 >> 101
56 >> 86) Hiroshi Tanahashi   >> 49.53 >> 51
57 >> 44) Tully Blanchard   >> 49.64 >> 109
58 >> 42) Ted DiBiase   >> 49.77 >> 110
59 >> 85) Manami Toyota   >> 50.1 >> 52
60 >> 46) CM Punk   >> 50.22 >> 105
61 >> 71) Dick Togo   >> 51.3 >> 66
62 >> 38) Mick Foley   >> 51.44 >> 121
63 >> 57) Bill Dundee   >> 52.55 >> 87
64 >> 66) Keiji Mutoh   >> 53.31 >> 74
65 >> 47) Brock Lesnar   >> 53.32 >> 110
66 >> 54) Greg Valentine   >> 53.62 >> 99
67 >> 51) Andre The Giant   >> 53.81 >> 105
68 >> 84) The Undertaker   >> 53.95 >> 59
69 >> 74) Atlantis   >> 54.04 >> 68
70 >> 63) Giant Baba   >> 54.1 >> 80
71 >> 78) Dynamite Kid   >> 54.19 >> 64
72 >> 55) Curt Hennig   >> 55.05 >> 100
73 >> 73) Chris Jericho   >> 55.65 >> 71
74 >> 65) Shinjiro Ohtani   >> 55.8 >> 80
75 >> 79) Terry Gordy   >> 56.14 >> 66
76 >> 104) Chris Hero   >> 56.69 >> 52
77 >> 58) Owen Hart   >> 57.35 >> 94
78 >> 93) Bob Backlund   >> 57.4 >> 57
79 >> 64) Sgt. Slaughter   >> 57.69 >> 87
80 >> 76) Hiroshi Hase   >> 58.41 >> 73
81 >> 83) Roddy Piper   >> 59.84 >> 67
82 >> 105) Akira Maeda   >> 60.37 >> 52
83 >> 75) Hulk Hogan   >> 60.65 >> 78
84 >> 92) Dusty Rhodes   >> 60.66 >> 62
85 >> 80) Tito Santana   >> 61.2 >> 74
86 >> 59) Samoa Joe   >> 61.21 >> 103
87 >> 102) Christian   >> 61.36 >> 56
88 >> 88) Sami Zayn   >> 61.62 >> 66
89 >> 89) Atsushi Onita   >> 61.78 >> 65
90 >> 101) The Rock   >> 61.93 >> 57
91 >> 103) Carlos Colon   >> 61.98 >> 56
92 >> 109) Larry Zbyszko   >> 62.27 >> 52
93 >> 72) Brian Pillman   >> 63.06 >> 86
94 >> 94) Shinsuke Nakamura   >> 63.13 >> 64
95 >> 87) Cesaro   >> 63.28 >> 69
96 >> 77) Rick Rude   >> 64 >> 83
97 >> 113) Sting   >> 64.33 >> 52
98 >> 111) Masa Fuchi   >> 64.67 >> 54
99 >> 82) Steve Williams   >> 65.47 >> 79
100 >> 81) Yoshihiro Tajiri   >> 65.84 >> 80


#4 TravJ1979

TravJ1979
  • Members
  • 1309 posts
  • Gender:Male
  • Location:Indiana

Posted 13 May 2016 - 06:27 PM

Thought I'd throw up a list of voters who were the high votes most often:

 

Dean Rasmussen  24
Mando>Eddie  24
Scarlet-Left  21
anarchistixx  14
John Steffy  12
Paul Völsch  12
The Great Puma  12
Alan Counian  11
andrew lacelle  11
notjaytabb  11
Tim Cooke  11
A Stock  10
MikeF  10
ShittyLittleBoots  10


#5 Grimmas

Grimmas

    a Wrestling Feminist

  • Members
  • 7900 posts
  • Gender:Male
  • Location:Toronto, Ontario, Canada

Posted 13 May 2016 - 06:47 PM

Here is the top 100 if you count only top ten votes: 

 

 
1 Ric Flair
2 Terry Funk
3 Stan Hansen
4 Mitsuharu Misawa
5 Kenta Kobashi
6 Toshiaki Kawada
7 Jumbo Tsuruta
8 Genichiro Tenryu
9 Daniel Bryan
10 Jerry Lawler
11 Negro Casas
12 Jushin Liger
13 Nick Bockwinkel
14 Rey Mysterio Jr
15 Bret Hart
16 Randy Savage
17 Eddie Guerrero
18 El Hijo del Santo
19 Tatsumi Fujinami
20 Shinya Hashimoto
21 Shawn Michaels
22 El Satanico
23 Vader
24 Yoshiaki Fujiwara
25 Steve Austin
26 Ricky Steamboat
27 Buddy Rose
28 Chris Benoit
29 Jun Akiyama
30 Harley Race
31 John Cena
32 William Regal
33 Kiyoshi Tamura
34 Volk Han
35 Andre the Giant
36 Jim Breaks
37 Dynamite Kid
38 Roddy Piper
39 Kurt Angle
40 Akira Hokuto
41 El Dandy
42 Dick Murdoch
43 Aja Kong
44 Arn Anderson
45 Bob Backlund
46 Hulk Hogan
47 Yuki Ishikawa
48 Billy Robinson
49 AJ Styles
50 Lou Thesz
51 Brock Lesnar
52 Hiroshi Tanahashi
53 Akira Taue
54 CM Punk
55 Manami Toyota
56 Curt Hennig
57 Meiko Satomura
58 Tully Blanchard
59 Tiger Mask
60 Masaaki Mochizuki
61 Mick Foley
62 Keiji Mutoh
63 Jack Brisco
64 Blue Panther
65 Ted DiBiase
66 Steve Grey
67 Dustin Rhodes
68 Sami Zayn
69 Devil Masami
70 Rock
71 Rick Rude
72 Bull Nakano
73 Owen Hart
74 Too Cold Scorpio
75 Scott Steiner
76 Antonio Inoki
77 Low Ki
78 Giant Baba
79 Brian Pillman
80 Minoru Suzuki
81 La Parka
82 Nigel McGuinness
83 Pat Patterson
84 Gorgeous George
85 Chigusa Nagayo
86 Eddie Gilbert
87 Jaguar Yokota
88 Atlantis
89 Fit Finlay
90 Mike Quackenbush
91 Kana
92 KENTA
93 Sting
94 Dusty Rhodes
95 Atsushi Onita
96 Buddy Rogers
97 Nobuhiko Takada
98 Rick Martel
99 Riki Choshu
100 Terry Gordy


#6 funkdoc

funkdoc

    free si oem

  • Members
  • 759 posts
  • Gender:Male

Posted 13 May 2016 - 09:26 PM

dang that "top 10 votes only" list is the coolest one!  like that seems to give the best "feel" of the tastes of the most active participants?  less lucha on that one though, which speaks to Dylan's point about lucha fans not getting behind anyone to the degree that WOS fans get behind Breaks & Grey as a cut above the rest.



#7 NintendoLogic

NintendoLogic

    Grim and frostbitten

  • Members
  • 2736 posts
  • Gender:Male

Posted 16 May 2016 - 10:29 PM

I decided to see what would happen if I combined the 2006 and 2016 lists. To accomplish this, I awarded each wrestler a certain number of points based on their ranking on each list (100 points for first place, 99 points for second place, etc., all the way down to 1 point for 100th place) and then added the points together. In the event of a tie, the tiebreak went to who placed highest on the 2016 list. Here's what it would look like:

 

1. Ric Flair
2. Jushin Liger
3. Mitsuharu Misawa
4. Toshiaki Kawada
5. Jumbo Tsuruta
6. Terry Funk
7. Stan Hansen
8. Kenta Kobashi
9. Eddie Guerrero
10. Bret Hart
11. Ricky Steamboat
12. Rey Mysterio
13. Vader
14. Genichiro Tenryu
15. Chris Benoit
16. Steve Austin
17. Shinya Hashimoto
18. El Hijo del Santo
19. Jerry Lawler
20. Akira Taue
21. Arn Anderson
22. Barry Windham
23. Harley Race
24. Negro Casas
25. Randy Savage
26. Aja Kong
27. Akira Hokuto
28. Nick Bockwinkel
29. William Regal
30. Jun Akiyama
31. Bobby Eaton
32. Shawn Michaels
33. Tatsumi Fujinami
34. Ted DiBiase
35. Billy Robinson
36. Shinjiro Ohtani
37. Dynamite Kid
38. Giant Baba
39. Owen Hart
40. Curt Hennig
41. Tully Blanchard
42. Blue Panther
43. El Dandy
44. Volk Han
45. Finlay
46. Dick Murdoch
47. Bull Nakano
48. Daniel Bryan
49. Ricky Morton
50. Mick Foley
51. Hiroshi Hase
52. Manami Toyota
53. Jack Brisco
54. Keiji Mutoh
55. Nobuhiko Takada
56. The Destroyer
57. Jaguar Yokota
58. Kiyoshi Tamura
59. El Satanico
60. Terry Gordy
61. John Cena
62. Mayumi Ozaki
63. Dustin Rhodes
64. Steve Williams
65. Devil Masami
66. Buddy Rose
67. Rick Martel
68. AJ Styles
69. Chigusa Nagayo
70. Yoshiaki Fujiwara
71. Riki Choshu
72. CM Punk
73. Brock Lesnar
74. Kurt Angle
75. Andre the Giant
76. Greg Valentine
77. Jim Breaks
78. Chris Jericho
79. Bill Dundee
80. Samoa Joe
81. Brian Pillman
82. Mariko Yoshida
83. Hulk Hogan
84. Dynamite Kansai
85. Rick Rude
86. Akira Maeda
87. Sgt. Slaughter
88. Ultimo Dragon
89. The Rock
90. Kyoko Inoue
91. Kazuo Yamazaki
92. Atlantis
93. Dick Togo
94. Bob Backlund
95. Tiger Mask
96. Dory Funk Jr.
97. Yuki Ishikawa
98. Antonio Inoki
99. Masahiro Chono
100. Lioness Asuka



#8 jushin muta liger

jushin muta liger
  • Members
  • 397 posts
  • Gender:Male

Posted 18 May 2016 - 11:01 AM

I went into the Megathread for something else but I found this thread on who is the Best Black Wrestler. Reading through it, I made a list of the results from the GWE.
 
I included Carlos Colon because looking at him, he looks Afro-Latino. I could've put in other Puerto Ricans like Savio Vega and Homicide but I thought Colon was obvious. Surprisingly no JYD.
 
49) Aja Kong   (4085 points, 83 ballots, 39.89 avg, high: 3 - anarchistxx, 2006: 18)
91) Too Cold Scorpio   (2521 points, 74 ballots, 67.27 avg, high: 1 - Mando>Eddie, 2006: 145)
101) The Rock   (2228 points, 57 ballots, 61.93 avg, high: 8 - anonymous, 2006: 64)
103) Carlos Colon   (2185 points, 56 ballots, 61.98 avg, high: 12 - El Boricua, 2006: honorable mention)
136) Butch Reed   (1189 points, 38 ballots, 69.71 avg, high: 24 - anonymous, 2006: honorable mention)
156) Mark Henry   (1007 points, 37 ballots, 73.78 avg, high: 42 - Phil Rippa, 2006: unranked)
234) Abdullah the Butcher   (396 pts, 17 ballots, 77.71 avg, high: 32 - El Boricua, 2006: honorable mention)
238) Sasha Banks   (360 pts, 13 ballots, 73.31 avg, high: 22 - Scarlet-Left, 2006: unranked)
248) Booker T   (316 pts, 12 ballots, 74.67 avg, high: 16 - Mando>Eddie, 2006: honorable mention)
250) Koko B Ware   (312 pts, 10 ballots, 69.80 avg, high: 19 - Mando>Eddie, 2006: unranked)
251) Ernie Ladd   (311 pts, 14 ballots, 78.79 avg, high: 44 - NotJayTabb, 2006: honorable mention)
270) Ricochet   (275 pts, 13 ballots, 79.85 avg, high: 46 - jackwebb, 2006: unranked)
274) Clive Myers   (271 pts, 12 ballots, 78.42 avg, high: 54 - PeteF3, 2006: honorable mention)
279) Ron Simmons   (239 pts, 8 ballots, 71.13 avg, high: 24 - Scarlet-Left, 2006: unranked)
352) Kamala   (128 pts, 7 ballots, 82.71 avg, high: 50 - ChuckScumm, 2006: unranked)
355) New Jack   (124 pts, 6 ballots, 80.30 avg, high: 25 - Mando>Eddie, 2006: unranked)
387) Norman Smiley   (97 pts, 6 ballots, 84.83 avg, high: 45 - anonymous, 2006: unranked)
466) Bob Sapp   (35 pts, 1 ballot, 66.00 avg, high: 66 - anonymous, 2006: unranked)
519) Rufus R. Jones   (14 pts, 1 ballot, 87.00 avg, high: 87 - Dean Rasmussen, 2006: unranked)
557) Kofi Kingston   (1 pt, 1 ballot, 100.00 avg, high: 100 - Jimmy Redman, 2006: unranked)




0 user(s) are reading this topic

0 members, 0 guests, 0 anonymous users