Steamboat vs. Bob Orton Jr. is pretty special.
Man... that brings back a bizarrely specific memory:
One of my wrestling fiends had a collection of Colosseum Home Videos. There was a match, and I am 90 per cent sure it was Steamboat vs Orton, that was on two different volumes of The Best of the WWF. I remember we were discussing if maybe it was an example of a "formula match" where two guys work basically the same match around the circuit... but then we cued them up and watched them back to back and it quickly became apparent that it was in fact the exact same match in the same building with the same fans...
That stands out in my memory more than the match itself, though I am sure it's a good one. I'm assuming it's the same on you mean.
I wonder how many other matches made more than one Colosseum tape.