Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: HHH taking over from Vince on RAW
ProWrestlingOnly.com Forums > Pro Wrestling > Pro Wrestling > Megathread archive
Pages: 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14
MARTYEWR
In fairness to the match, Punk kicked out of at least one Pedigree and it took like four finishers (at least) to beat him. From the sounds of it (I didn't see the show), it wasn't a burial, although I'm still not exactly overly excited about the angle. On a more hilarious note, supposedly Nash might've injured himself doing the run-in.
Hollinger.
Yeah, it wasn't a burial at all. Punk looked stronger than Hunter during the match, and took three pedigrees and a jacknife before he went down. It was overbooked like crazy, but no one came away looking much different than before the match.

(Also, the match had been really fucking good before all the interference)
Bix
It was far from a burial. In fact, it was as even and giving a match as you could hope for. How often in recent years has anyone kicked out of the Pedigree without any shenanigans (a long delay or something like that) in something other than a Wrestlemania main event?

And I agree that it was a hell of a match before the clusterfuckery.
kjh
QUOTE(Hollinger. @ Sep 19 2011, 06:54 PM) *
It was overbooked like crazy, but no one came away looking much different than before the match.


Isn't that a slight problem? Working even with Hunter doesn't hurt Punk, but nonetheless it keeps him at the same level slightly below the more established Hunter, Cena and Orton. Which shouldn't be surprising as this storyline has been more about putting over Hunter first and Punk second. I'm not sure staying the course with a pat hand is what's needed at a time when house show attendance and ratings are both flagging.
Coffey
It wasn't a burial at all. Punk took 3 Pedigree's and a Jackknife Powerbomb. It was just a clusterfuck. Miz & Truth did their run-in, beat-up both Punk & HHH. Then put Punk on top of HHH for the pinfall...HHH kicked out. Then later, Punk went for a pin, and Truth pulled him off (which didn't make any sense to what they were doing earlier). Johnny Ace came down and wouldn't let the new ref (old ref was bumped by Miz/Truth) get in the ring to make the pinfall following a Pedigree. Which made it look like he wanted Hunter to lose (which would make sense, from a power play point of view). Then when Punk hit the Go-To-Sleep, he let the new ref go in to make the pinfall count (which is the one Truth broke up). Then Johnny Ace sent a text, which caused Nash to do a run-in. Then Nash beat-up BOTH Punk and Nash (which AGAIN didn't make any fuckin' sense whatsoever, since I thought Ace wanted HHH to lose).

It was just a bigger fuck-up than the ending of NXT season 2.
NintendoLogic
Yeah, the Pedigree that put Punk down was the third of the match. It wasn't a burial, just an overbooked mess. Just the latest example of PPVs being used to build anticipation for Raw rather than the other way around.
Coffey
QUOTE(NintendoLogic @ Sep 19 2011, 02:56 PM) *
Yeah, the Pedigree that put Punk down was the third of the match. It wasn't a burial, just an overbooked mess. Just the latest example of PPVs being used to build anticipation for Raw rather than the other way around.

Which is silly because ratings are down anyway and they're always, no matter what, going to get killed by Monday Night Football. If anything this should be the time when they're trying to increase Pay-Per-View buys, not television ratings. It's O.K. though because now they'll have the guy that played Wolverine in some terrible skits shilling his new terrible Rock 'Em, Sock 'Em Robots movie.

At least the Mark Henry build-up was executed well.
jdw
QUOTE(NintendoLogic @ Sep 19 2011, 09:02 AM) *
Main event started out as a really good brawl and ended up a total clusterfuck. Miz and Truth came out and attacked both guys, then Johnny Ace came out and sent a text message, then Nash came out and attacked both guys. He jackknifed Punk and tried to do the same to HHH, but HHH hit him with a sledgehammer. Then he Pedigreed Punk for the pin.



"You're the real star
of the promotion, Trip.
You and me, brother."



John
rovert
Forget the fake ones in this thread WWE are getting the real deal:




QUOTE
The Muppets come to Raw on Halloween night
Hollinger.
It wasn't like Trips playing Superman and taking on Nash w/ a sledgehammer. Nash was kicking the shit out of him, then took his time clearing off the announce table, turned around and he got cracked in the head. It was actually a neat visual, because they kept Trips out of frame until the shot. And then Nash for some reason bumped into a Christ pose, arms out and ankles crossed.
Ricky Jackson
QUOTE(rovert @ Sep 19 2011, 12:38 PM) *
Forget the fake ones in this thread WWE are getting the real deal:




QUOTE
The Muppets come to Raw on Halloween night



Honestly, this could be a lot of fun. Although, wouldn't a match involving Kermit break Muppet kayfabe for the live audience? wink.gif
Loss
The Muppets on Raw could be outstanding with good writing. That's a big "with".

(They may even be great without it.)
Bob Morris
QUOTE(Loss @ Sep 19 2011, 07:51 AM) *
Punk beating Cena two months in a row, then losing to Del Rio and Cena, then Punk losing to HHH and Cena beating Del Rio. Yikes. They have no clue of how they want to position people or where they want to go long-term. None. There needs to be room for reactive thinking in booking plans without a doubt, but WWE would improve so much if someone would put together something that says where they want to be in 3, 6 and 12 months and book backwards from each of those points. Vince used to always do that. I do think politics played a part in all of this getting so bad, but I think the bigger issue is incompetence and that the system itself is broken. This is the consequence of not thinking past the next Raw. Had they played their cards right, Punk could just be returning right about now and they'd have something really hot to carry them until Rock comes in to start building the Cena match.


This. A thousand times this.

Obviously, you need to be able to do some adjustments as you go along from show to show because of unanticipated events (i.e, injuries) but you need to have at least some sense of where you want to be in the long term. Booking show to show, as appears to be the case, doesn't work that well. You might stumble upon something really good, but then you aren't going to understand how to properly follow up on it.

Then again, our society has a lot of "instant gratification" and "live for the moment" and "short-term thinking" these days, so I suppose what WWE is doing is par for the course in today's environment.
Bob Morris
QUOTE(rovert @ Sep 19 2011, 01:38 PM) *
Forget the fake ones in this thread WWE are getting the real deal:




QUOTE
The Muppets come to Raw on Halloween night



I demand that HHH sell for Statler and Waldorf just like Milton Berle did.

For those who don't know what I'm talking about:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PGfx3QAV64M
Bix
QUOTE(Hollinger. @ Sep 19 2011, 04:31 PM) *
It wasn't like Trips playing Superman and taking on Nash w/ a sledgehammer. Nash was kicking the shit out of him, then took his time clearing off the announce table, turned around and he got cracked in the head. It was actually a neat visual, because they kept Trips out of frame until the shot. And then Nash for some reason bumped into a Christ pose, arms out and ankles crossed.

As someone who normally hates the sledgehammer usage because it's so ridiculous, I agree that was a great spot.

The camerawork and camera switching was top-notch for the whole match and really added to the presentation.
Bix
QUOTE(Loss @ Sep 19 2011, 05:06 PM) *
The Muppets on Raw could be outstanding with good writing. That's a big "with".

(They may even be great without it.)

They pulled off The Price Is Raw about as well as could be expected so I'm thinking this will go well.
El-P
QUOTE(Bob Morris @ Sep 19 2011, 04:02 PM) *
I demand that HHH sell for Statler and Waldorf just like Milton Berle did.

For those who don't know what I'm talking about:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PGfx3QAV64M


That's hilarious.
Strummer
not that many care anymore but Powell at prowrestling.net is saying Vince is returning to TV soon so that's where the angle seems to be going
kjh
Dave said the same thing in the Observer. Geno did a good post regarding this at Cageside Seats: You mad? Vince McMahon reportedly pissed off at Raw on Sept. 19 in Cleveland
Mad Dog
Bill Simmons randomly went off of HHH during his podcast this week and said he ruined the Punk angle and Punk. It was really weird because Simmons has never really done that before.
jdw
Simmons really liked the Punk angle, and one got the sense that it was something that sucked him back in to watching at least the Punk angle. It comes across that Bill is in the camp that found the angle didn't go in / sustain the direction that he initially thought was cool, so he's fucking pissed off. I don't think the only one. smile.gif

John
Mad Dog
Yeah, I saw he had Punk on last month for an interview but haven't listened to that episode yet. Cousin Sal was on for their football picks and he just randomly went off on it after talking about the Mayweather fight.
cm funk
Good for Bill Simmons for saying what a shitload of people are thinking

My interest in WWE is fucking dead at this point aside from the "We Appreciate You Mark Henry" monster push. I don't even like or care about CM Punk right now, and before this whole charade began I would have claimed him as my 2nd favorite active wrestler after Mysterio

If it wasn't for Rock coming back around and the annual gear up for Rumble-->Mania what would they have going that could possibly qualify as a draw?
Tim Evans
Cena vs Undertaker? I would have said Cena/Rey but I doubt Rey is coming back before Mania.
Ricky Jackson
QUOTE(Tim Evans @ Sep 22 2011, 06:55 PM) *
Cena vs Undertaker? I would have said Cena/Rey but I doubt Rey is coming back before Mania.


Was the match between Cena and Rey from a few months back the first between the two, at least since they both became huge stars? If so, it was a little short-sighted to just casually throw a first-time match between arguably the two biggest babyfaces of the last several years on TV with no build. But as we all know, the old rules of promoting "rasslin" no longer apply.

Speaking of which, and I know I'm not the first to bring this up, but in the last few years I've envisioned Cena vs Undertaker as a modern version of Hogan vs Andre from Mania 3 (sans the legendary status, but hopefully better worked), with the twist being that the younger guy turns heel and does the job. Maybe for Mania 29 and Takers final match.
Dooley
QUOTE(jdw @ Sep 22 2011, 06:15 PM) *
Simmons really liked the Punk angle, and one got the sense that it was something that sucked him back in to watching at least the Punk angle. It comes across that Bill is in the camp that found the angle didn't go in / sustain the direction that he initially thought was cool, so he's fucking pissed off. I don't think the only one. smile.gif

John


Nope, it really seems the consensus. Not just among wrestling fans, real people.
cm funk
QUOTE(Ricky Jackson @ Sep 22 2011, 10:39 PM) *
QUOTE(Tim Evans @ Sep 22 2011, 06:55 PM) *
Cena vs Undertaker? I would have said Cena/Rey but I doubt Rey is coming back before Mania.


Was the match between Cena and Rey from a few months back the first between the two, at least since they both became huge stars? If so, it was a little short-sighted to just casually throw a first-time match between arguably the two biggest babyfaces of the last several years on TV with no build. But as we all know, the old rules of promoting "rasslin" no longer apply.


I believe it was, and it was absolutely retarded to give it away on RAW with less than 2 hrs build the way they did. Maybe they just figured Rey was going to be out of action for a long time and they should do the match while they could? At least could have saved it for the next week's show and popped a rating....
jdw
Any updates or thoughts on how this is going?

Martin:

WWE Raw Report by Todd Martin

QUOTE
On the downside, this HHH angle is just terrible. Who cares if HHH retains his COO job or not? It’s not like things are any different with him in charge. It’s not like he’s had the role for any real period of time. It’s not like he seems to care much about having the job. It’s not like he’s going to leave the show if they remove him from the job. And yet we have to listen to the announcers go on and on and on about it all two hours.

What’s even more annoying is it all feels so fake and contrived. HHH has only been in his role a few months and things are the same as they always are. They were doing tons of angles at a breakneck pace before HHH was in charge. A few angles with Miz and Truth don’t feel like anything out of the ordinary. Yet now the story is things are out of control and so everyone talks about that even though it doesn’t remotely feel that way. It’s just the directive, like everyone must say “WWE Universe” over and over again even though nobody in the real world would be caught dead using that asinine expression.

It’s fine if the heels say that things are out of control. They are after all heels, out to get rid of HHH the babyface. But when all the face wrestlers, announcers and cameramen seem to agree, it just feels ridiculous. It’s not that it inspires anger at the faces for doing that, although they certainly don’t come off well. It’s simply unbelievable that those characters are acting that way.

We’ve seen cars blowing up, vehicular attacks, gang beatdowns, big injury angles to top stars and a cavalcade of hotshot angles and now the cameramen are walking off the job because they’re terrified of a Miz run-in? The wrestlers are unanimous in turning on HHH as an authority figure because of a Miz run-in? It’s just bad storytelling. They haven’t made the stakes feel important or the actions feel believable, and by acting like it’s this huge deal it will be even harder next month when they try to hotshot another big angle.


Thoughts?

John
Bix
It was kind of interesting visually but if they planned this at all they should have done more to build it up.
Ricky Jackson
Check the new comments thread for my take on it. (and no, I'm not secretly Todd Martin) I should have put it here but I totally forgot about this thread.
Dylan Waco
I liked the presentation an awful lot on the ppv and that is coming from someone who hates HHH and generally has little interest in ever seeing him again.

Liked the presentation even more on Monday Night.

Coffey
I think Todd Martin completely missed the point. It's not about "A Miz run-in." First of all, it was Miz & R-Truth both, with weapons, doing an attack, from the crowd, after a Hell in a Cell match.

Secondly, and most importantly, it's not about that attack. It's about the motifs BEHIND that attack. The entire "conspiracy" angle. Which I thought Jerry Lawler did a pretty good job explaining, in the ring, on the microphone last night...but I guess it still went over the head of a lot of people.
jdw
Todd had the Lawler stuff:

QUOTE
Jerry Lawler then came in the ring. He said he agreed with some things said and disagreed with others. Lawler said he thinks the show is spiraling out of control. Lawler said someone behind the scenes is trying to sabotage HHH’s job and won’t stop until HHH is gone. Thus, Lawler concluded it is ultimately HHH’s fault that things are so dangerous for the performers.


Sounds like he just doesn't think the angle works. Really, has anything changed under Trip that wasn't there when Vince or all the various GM's have been in charge? There is a logic hole there.

John
Dylan Waco
I agree that there is a logic hole to a degree, but it is worth recalling that the storyline reason for Trips ascension was because of how out of control things had gotten under Vince. He was installed to clean up Vince's mess. In kayfabe World it is clear the mess has gotten worse and deeper since Vince left. So it stands to reason that the guy installed to solve problems, making things worse, would be called to the carpet. Or something
jdw
Was the mess when Vince got replaced any worse than the mess Vince was "causing" when feuding with one of the most popular performers in company history: Stone Cold? Or any number of other faces Vince feuded with? smile.gif

And for logic, if the Board cared about how Vince was treating Punk, how exactly did they think things would change by installing the Doufus Son In Law in his place?

"It's WWE Creative, Jake."

Probably best not to think too hard about it. The "WWE Universe" has holes the size of wormholes in scifi universes.

John
KrisZ
CM Punk speaks on last night's angle

QUOTE
I think a lot of people are missing the point. Fans and coworkers alike. Walking out is a pussy move. There's a huge difference.....in what I did. I want change, and I can't change shit from my couch. I'm in the fox hole. I'm getting it done. I stayed to fight......and I'm fighting for change. You can protest, violently or peacefully without actually showing up. Walking out isn't a solution...at least not one that I've ever seen work. Hold 'em up. Make them change. Don't just walk out, or lay down. Fight. This goes for fans.....as well. Bored? Don't like @johncena ? Want more @ZackRyder ? Show up and be heard. Don't be a pussy and just tweet about it. I want change, and I'll stand and fight for it even if I'm alone. Popular or unpopular, I could care less. Take your voting and shove it. Actions speaks louder than words. Except mine. My words are pretty awesome. No think about all that, and hopefully you'll get it. Too many tweets from me. Misspellings abound. You CAN'T protest without showing up. I am not Gandhi. I will kick your face. Don't like HHH as COO? Punch him in the face. I did. It's wrestling, not the NBA. Next high kick to Johnny "Funkhauser" Ace won't be an accident.
Ricky Jackson
I feel validated that kayfabe CM Punk agrees with my assessment of last night's angle. tongue.gif
jdw


"Walking out is a pussy move. There's a huge difference.....
in what I did. I want change, and I can't change shit from
my couch. I'm in the fox hole. I'm getting it done. I stayed
to fight......and I'm fighting for change."


You have to love storyline consistancy.

I feel story for Punk because from what everyone says, he's not this fucking stupid. But Vince, The Idiot Daughter and The Doufus Son In Law cut a nice check each pay period, so he'll happily mouth their bullshit.

John
Tim Evans
I just don't get why all the people that walked off on Raw last night are appearing on SD this Friday? Isn't HHH in charge of that show too?
NintendoLogic
Personally, I think not even coming out to take a stand one way or the other is a much bigger pussy move.
NintendoLogic
QUOTE(Tim Evans @ Oct 4 2011, 09:41 PM) *
I just don't get why all the people that walked off on Raw last night are appearing on SD this Friday? Isn't HHH in charge of that show too?


You can't let a labor dispute get in the way of the Big Show's return.
KrisZ
They specified that RAW was the out of control show. Teddy Long runs Smackdown even though Trips is the main boss
NintendoLogic
So does that mean the anonymous GM is coming back? Or maybe they should make Teddy the Raw GM too since he apparently already has the power to show up and book matches whenever he feels like it.
KrisZ
They've never taken away the GM podium and we could actually get a payoff of that angle here.
Matt D
Do we get Foley before or after the heel (Ace, Steph, Vince, whoever) authority figure or after him?
Ricky Jackson
All I know is HHH better fix this damn mess before the Muppets show up on Halloween. You can't have them appear in an unsafe work environment like Raw. It's just another potential lawsuit waiting to happen.
KrisZ
Regal weighs in.

QUOTE
Some people have asked about the walkout on Raw.My personal reasons for my action was that I think HHH has enough on his plate being the COO.I know exactly what it takes to be in charge of Raw and it comes at a dear price(or it did with me).HHH is in charge of the WWE.He needs to concentrate on the company as a whole and put a suitable candidate in charge of the Raw brand.
jdw
Lordy... think is going to get really stupid.

Wait... "already is" really stupid.

John
El-P
Wait a minute, Twitter is the new way for kayfaybe now ?
S.L.L.
This is the angle they should have run after Punk left with the belt. Running it now...well, it's still a cool idea in theory but....

1. It needed more time to build up.
2. It's too soon after they inevitably blew their last cool idea for an angle. You need time for us to forget that they always blow these things.
3. It's an angle where - as it stands - the central figure is Triple H. It's really, really hard to get me psyched up about that. Especially when you remember #2.

On the other hand, the Muppets are the kings of working in dangerous environments. If the payoff to all of this is that Trips has to step down and Kermit takes over as CEO because he has a better track record of keeping a show running where the performers are all completely out of control, I could support that.
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2013 Invision Power Services, Inc.