Jump to content
Pro Wrestling Only

Shinobu Kandori


Grimmas

Recommended Posts

I read somewhere recently and have always seen passing comments that suggests that Joshi fans or maybe even fans more broadly are or were at one time really down on Kandori. Has there been an active disdain for her? Can someone explain this if it is a real thing or point me to some place to read up on it?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I don't think there was "active disdain" for her necessarily, but she was not particularly highly thought of compared to her peers. I feel like most Joshi fans would have called her average, very few, if anybody, would have called her great and nobody would have called her there favorite wrestler. If you took a poll in 2001 among Joshi fans of "best Joshi wrestler ever" she would struggle to make the top 25. I would actually say part of the "legend" of the Hokuto match for Joshi fans in the late 90s/early 2000s was that "it was amazing that Hokuto had a match that great with someone as average as Kandori."

 

I think it has more to do with ignorance creating a narrative that never got lifted. She didn't work the Go go go style Joshi was known for so that is working against her already. Combine that with how expensive tapes were at the time and you kind of convince yourself she's not worth watching. You'd see the chain match against Bull on a Schneider Comp and think "great carry job by Bull" and go back to skipping past the LLPW tape listings.

 

So not really active disdain. More of an "average" rep and if you were average, you weren't getting watched at 20 bucks a tape.

 

Obviously she was a great wrestler.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I don't think there was "active disdain" for her necessarily, but she was not particularly highly thought of compared to her peers. I feel like most Joshi fans would have called her average, very few, if anybody, would have called her great and nobody would have called her there favorite wrestler. If you took a poll in 2001 among Joshi fans of "best Joshi wrestler ever" she would struggle to make the top 25. I would actually say part of the "legend" of the Hokuto match for Joshi fans in the late 90s/early 2000s was that "it was amazing that Hokuto had a match that great with someone as average as Kandori."

 

I think it has more to do with ignorance creating a narrative that never got lifted. She didn't work the Go go go style Joshi was known for so that is working against her already. Combine that with how expensive tapes were at the time and you kind of convince yourself she's not worth watching. You'd see the chain match against Bull on a Schneider Comp and think "great carry job by Bull" and go back to skipping past the LLPW tape listings.

 

So not really active disdain. More of an "average" rep and if you were average, you weren't getting watched at 20 bucks a tape.

 

Obviously she was a great wrestler.

Ahh... got it.

 

Thanks a ton.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The best place to search for older views on Joshi Puroresu is Mike Lorefice's site.

 

On Hokuto vs. Kandori:

 

"Must see. Arguably the best women's singles match ever and the best example of a wrestler making a match an all-time classic on their own."

 

"No female was ever better than the 1993 version of Hokuto, and you could make a strong case that no male was either. She was the real total package – psychology, selling, drama, intensity, ability to elevate any opponent, work, charisma, etc. She could have found a way to have an excellent match with Kandori, who rarely if ever had excellent matches, because Hokuto was just that good at this time."

 

"Kandori deserves credit for her selling as well. With Kandori, everything comes down to her respect for her opponent. If you are a nobody, you’ll be treated as such, but if you are also a star she’ll find ways to put you over. She might not necessarily sell often, but her selling instills into the audience the feeling of an accomplishment on her opponent’s part. Kandori isn’t the world’s greatest actor, but she always remembered to stay down long enough, and didn’t pull that sudden rejuvenation stemming from the opportunity to do a move crap we get from Super Koji and friends."

 

"This allowed Kandori to be on offense most of the match, which she believes is her divine right anyway."

 

And that's just one match.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 4 years later...

Shinobu Kandori looked pretty great in the original JWP, something that was barely explored by the community 5 years ago:

 Shinobu Kandori vs. Miss A (7/13/89)
 Shinobu Kandori vs. Harley Saito (7/19/90)
Rumi Kazama & Shinobu Kandori vs. Devil Masami & Itsuki Yamazaki (JWP 9/30/90)
Miss A & Harley Saito vs. Shinobu Kandori & Rumi Kazama (JWP 10/10/90)
Mayumi Ozaki & Rumi Kazama vs. Shinobu Kandori & Harley Saito (JWP 1/6/1991)
 Dynamite Kansai & The Scorpion vs. Shinobu Kandori & Harley Saito (8/4/1991)

 

I had never heard of the Saito singles before, and it absolutely blew me away. I also stumbled upon a Satomura singles in 2007 or so that was really great too and something overlooked. I look forward to diving more into Kandoris work in LLPW and the more obscure JWP handhelds. She could crack my Top 50 next time we do a list.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

That Saito/Kandori match is amazing. Definitely check it out if you like Kandori's work. 

Kandori is my #1 Joshi, I'd say. There was something evidently special about her. Her aura of legit toughness is hard to match, and that's something that'll always get me on someone's side. She was quite charismatic as well. She's not just great submission and throws. The Brock Lesnar comparison is interesting as he's similar. There is a massive personality underlying there that doesn't necessarily get captured on first look and when it comes out, it's amazing. Kandori is quite adaptable as well. The Hokuto matches come off like dramatic fights (they are also my #1 & #2 Joshi matches), the Kudo matches are weapon brawls, the Hotta is more shooty based. And she somehow keeps her style and who she is alive despite the type of match she is wrestling in. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Love seeing the Kandori love. She is my #1 female wrestler ever and will be absurdly high for me (like silly high to some folks). I'll come back with a more complete defense/discussion of why later, but I'm glad to see some early praise.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I ranked Shinobu Kandori 70th in 2016 and I fucking blew it with that one. Kandori is amazing. She's what Brock Lesnar could have been. Amazing seller, unique offense but what really puts her over the top is her aura. She always feels larger than life and that allows her best stuff to transcend the typical best stuff of someones career. One of the talking points you'll often see about Daniel Bryan is that he has the best match wrestlers X, Y, Z etc. Well Kandori is involved in the best 3 Akira Hokuto matches, and maybe the best matches in the careers of Bull Nakano, Devil Masami, Yumiko Hotta & Harley Saito. And while maybe not their absolute best matches, she had top tier matches against Megumi Kudo, Kyoko Inoue, Manami Toyota & Meiko Satomura. Kandori was a special performer. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Kandori is quickly becoming my favourite female wrestler (not yet, but she's growing on me faster than Aja and Hokuto back then). I hope she finishes, at least, at the top 50 for 2026. To me, she's like top 30-25 contender right now (and I still haven't watched the Devil Masami match).

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I had Kandori at 81 in 2016 and that was at least 50 spots too low. It's too early to say for certain, but she might end up as my highest ranked woman in 2026. I think the fact she's not a "traditional" joshi candidate helps her case with me - much like it did in 2016 - in that some of the stuff that I struggle with in joshi at large isn't as prevalent with her. That's not me saying she's better than your Hokutos or Kongs or Jaguars because she works more like William Regal than Manami Toyota (I'm not even sure that's true anyway), but she's different enough from the norm that it's noticeable to me. She channels that badass aura as well as anyone, and believably so. I never realised in the past how insanely charismatic she was, but holy shit did she have stuuuupid amounts of charisma. There are times where she feels like a Fujiwara trainee as she'll lackadaisically apply an armbar just to see how her opponent will react, which is especially fun when it's some girl down the totem pole and Kandori KNOWS she can't get out of it, because that usually leads to someone at ringside or the opponent's tag partner throwing a fit and Kandori laughing at everyone because, fuck it, what is anybody realistically going to do to her? She's my favourite seller in joshi and her KO selling is phenomenal. She has a grasp of hierarchy that she'll work into matches in amazingly compelling ways that'll make me care more about Kyoko Inoue than I ever could've imagined. An absolute artist when it comes to the inter-promotional wrestling, which is really the best kind of wrestling. She has the input and she has the output and there still seems to be out of nowhere incredible stuff trickling down from whoever (Jetlag) is grabbing these JWP or LLPW shows hardly anybody has ever talked about before (like the Kandori/Endo v Hotta/Maekawa tag from 8/15/97, or really just anything with Hotta). She was phenomenal and she gets 10 recs because why not. 

 

SHINOBU KANDORI YOU SHOULD WATCH:

v Harley Saito (JWP, 7/19/90)

w/Harley Saito v Dynamite Kansai & The Scorpion (JWP, 8/4/91)

v Akira Hokuto (AJW, 4/2/93)

w/Eagle Sawai v Aja Kong & Akira Hokuto (AJW, 4/11/93)

v Kyoko Inoue (AJW, 8/25/93)

v Akira Hokuto (AJW, 12/6/93)

w/Utazo Hozumi v Bull Nakano & Takako Inoue (LLPW, 11/9/93)

w/Mizuki Endo v Yumiko Hotta & Kimiko Maekawa (LLPW, 8/15/97)

v Yumiko Hotta (LLPW, 3/21/98)

v Manami Toyota (AJW, 8/23/98)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Kandori is one of those wrestlers who is both overrated and underrated, IMO. She used to be overlooked and unfairly dismissed (e.g, previous Dreamslam reviews claimed Hokuto carried her, which is clear nonsense). But the pendulum might have swung too far in the other direction as some people now claim she actually outworked Hokuto. 

Makai Club #1 did a good job capturing her strengths. I'll probably rank her but in the bottom half. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 2 weeks later...

I said earlier I would outline my case for Kandori in a little more detail because – as people who participate in GME know all too well I think – I am going to be crazy high on her. This is one of the few times (maybe only) I will do such an extensive review. I find it difficult to make an argument for something akin to “objective” greatness and as you can see… I get wordy. However, if I am going to have her as a top 10 contender, I feel obligated to in this case.

In 2016 I said Kandori was my favorite female wrestler ever.  At the time she took it by a country mile. The gap has closed between her and quite a few others, but she remains at the top of the list for me. What’s more, in the time since I posted that she moved from just being my favorite to being – least with more conviction – my “best”. It isn’t damning with faint praise to make a gendered distinction either. That places her #7 on my working list (told you it would be silly high to some), with room to move up

Five years is a long time. I am sure I will talk more about her and I am sure conversation about her will ebb and flow, especially since – as Microstatistics alluded to – the pendulum seems to kind of be swinging her favor right now. Hell, maybe I will come down a bit on her in that time, but I wanted to make my base case for her as a potential high vote out the gates for the 2026 project and I had some time to think and write about it recently. I’m going to break it down into some sections that I think highlight her across-the-board strengths.

 

Top Matches

I think Kandori has a fairly strong, well rounded case, but the biggest and most impressive section of her resume is her top matches. Kandori’s top 5-10 matches stand up to just about anyone in wrestling. While tastes will vary, looking at my current GME list she is currently part of my #1, #6, #19, #37, and #56 matches of all time.  But that is, again, personal taste. Let’s think more broadly and take a sampling of some of her top/hyped matches.

v Sato (7/18/87)

v Devil (7/14/88)

v Saito (7/19/90)

w/Saito v Dynamite and The Scorpion (8/4/1991)

v Hokuto (4/2/1993)

v Inoue (8/25/93)

v Hotta (9/23/93)

v Hokuto (12/6/1993)

w/Hokuto v Bull and Aja (3/27/94)

v Bull (Chain – 7/14/94)

v Kudo (Street – 1/5/97)

v Kudo (Barb Wire – 3/14/97)

v Hotta 3/21/98)

v Toyota (8/23/98)

v Satomura (2/12/07)

Take your top 5-10 from that list (or maybe I am even missing something in this rough top 15) and I think it stacks up against just about anyone in terms of match quality (a point made a while back by Dylan and others). I often think of Kandori as a big match worker, and one that has an argument as THE big match worker. She has an acute ability to go out and have a great match and bring something special to that match (more on this to come). While it is obvious from the volume of matches above that she isn’t just carried to quality matches, it is important to note that she is a pretty active part of why each of these matches were great. For what might be a counterintuitive example, I would argue that she is absolute crucial to that 94 tag match. I often see people talk about everyone but her, but Kandori is irreplicable in that match. She navigates all the complex dynamics and does lot to moderate the pace of everything throughout. It is a long match and her particular approach to wrestling regulates much of it perfectly. It is a case where the often more “unsexy” parts of wrestling like pacing are so important in creating big matches and why her specific skill set warrants bigtime consideration.

Personally, I focus a bit more on peak as a product of my watching patterns and habits,so  this is a big category for me.  When you were at your best… how good were you? That is something I find fascinating. When Kandori has been at her best, there just aren’t many I think are better. What’s more, I am not going to make a real longevity argument because I haven’t done as much of a dive into the latter parts of her career and am still sorting through some of the earlier stuff we have readily available, but the fact that she has 2 pretty commonly hyped matches 20 years apart is not nothing.

 

Singular Performer/Uniqueness

Spoiler alert: this section is the longest because it grounds much of what I will discuss in later sections. I often will harp on “singularity” in my reviews or my effusive praise of particularly wrestlers. Lots of folks carry the quality with them, for sure, but Kandori stands out even among them and it really elevates much of her work. To me, being singular or unique just means that through the combination of their skills, tendencies, and approach a wrestler has carved out a distinctive place in wrestling. In turn, it is hard to imagine someone else doing what they do in a match, feud, or run.  This is sort of a sticky one. The more I think about this the more I think it isn’t a quality that is unique among elite wrestlers. Rather, I think any wrestler worth their salt should do this to some degree. That said, I would argue that Kandori excels in this regard. I’m going to touch on a few quick examples that I think serve as microcosms for her larger body of work

I’ll hit the big example first, I count Hokuto vs Kandori DreamSlam as the greatest match of all time and one of the primary reasons is that Kandori presents a challenge to Hokuto that no one else on earth could. As much as I love Aja and Bull and even Dump in the way they bully someone and come off as a “final boss” type figure, Kandori’s danger is different. She is the boss that makes you realize the big scary one was just the penultimate hurdle where the real greatest challenge of all comes from someone who might not look quite as scary, but is cerebral and technical. Ok, I’ll get away from the metaphor because it has its limits here, but you get the point.  In the above-mentioned greatest match ever, Hokuto is rightly praised as an other-worldly protagonist, and this isn’t to take anything away from that. However, I find the idea that she was much better than Kandori on that night silly. I would argue that without the combination of malice, technique, and violence that Kandori brings and without her setting the tone with really her facial expressions as much as anything early on Hokuto could have never put on that performance. Now, don’t hear what I am not saying.  To Microstatistics more specific point, I don’t think Kandori necessarily outperformed Hokuto. I personally like her style more in the match, but I think it is two top shelf performances coming together in a really special way that night (like probably most truly elite matches)

Let me take on another example in a little more detail that I think brings her singularity into some focus, the 8/25/93 match against Kyoko Inoue. While this is not the best Kandori match, it might be one of her best performances. Again, this isn’t to take anything away from Kyoko Inoue, who is awesome and is definitely awesome in this match. First and foremost, there is just not anyone who could present the brand of danger Kandori brings in this. No one I can think of at least.  She is dangerous from anywhere and everywhere. There is just this sense that no matter where she is she might grab Inoue and finish her right there and then. It is almost relentless through much of this match, even when Inoue is sort of laying it in early on. Weather she is hitting a slick leg sweep from her back and moving right into a submission after taking a beating or firing out of the corner with headbutts, she sells while always giving you the sense that she could turn the match around in the blink of an eye. This compounded by her great nonverbal work. Her facial expressions and gestures bring a lot to a match. In this, I think there are moments in many of her matches where her intensity and her entire approach to a wrestling match just elevates the match often very subtly. In this match there are two really good, simple early examples. First, when she comes out of the corner after taking some offense and is pissed, just leveling Inoue with a few (aforementioned) headbutts in the first couple minutes of the match. She later takes a baseball slide drop kick on the outside and her shoe is untied. Kandori turns tying her shoe into a fucking part of the match. She seems absolutely furious that her shoe is untied and walks around like Inoue is going to take a bad one for it. It is in the little ways she responds to these things. In the first she is elevating the pace and violence and establishing that no matter how bad it looks for her she is dangerous. The second she is letting something linger a minute to provide gravity (to something sort of frivolous no less). What’s more, I think these are pretty par for the course for her. She does stuff like this all of the time. Kandori is a master at elevating the pace, intensity, and/or violence in match at just the right time and she doesn’t always need to be touching her opponent to do it. It is just her entire approach to who she is in a match that I think makes everything bigger and better than it would otherwise be.  The final aspect of her singularity is how efficient she can be. This obviously contributes to the first part of my discussion of this match. Kandori isn’t exactly a minimalist, but as many pointed out both during the 2016 project and the recent start up for 2026, she isn’t exactly like many of her peers. She is more grounded, pace oriented. I would argue most of the great joshi workers have good to great psychology, but Kandori works hers differently and finds a way to make it work with divergant opponents. In this match Kandori gets a whole lot done with a rear naked choke and a fujiwara arm bar, especially down the stretch. The last quarter of this match feels like every time she puts a rear naked on it might be over.  She makes simple holds look absolutely deadly and to Inoue’s credit she is selling everything like it could be the end.  But it is this ferocious, relentless, and well-timed application of the sleeper that caries all the intensity of the match at the end. Finally, I love this finish. This is a wonderful way for Kandori to end a match given how she has articulated her danger throughout. She has Inoue so bound up and locks on a makeshift americana and that is it. Despite it feeling very much like Inoue gets the lion’s share of offense Kandori’s offense does more damage and – again – she could finish it at any moment.

Another very brief example is the T. Inoue/ Hotta vs Kandori/Miki match where much of the match is built around Hotta and Inoue being desperate to keep Kandori on the outside and not allowing her to ever have isolation, esp with Inoue. Once she makes the hot tag it isn’t the cleanest or best sequence, but there is this awesome little moment where Hotta comes off the top and sort of misses the kick. Kandori is standing their bracing herself and realizes it doesn’t hit hard. She doesn’t just fall; she drops in for a straight ankle lock and the crowd sort of reacts like that could be it. Her aura of danger is not the flashiest part of the match. It isn’t the most overt or exciting… but it is the best part of it. This is a match that is good, but not elite to me, but it still reflects what Kandori brings and how it can be used to make everything better.

This is really underdeveloped, but the closest sort of adjacent wrestlers to Kandori in this regard are maybe like Fujiwara, M. Suzukij, and maybe, oddly enough, Bryan? I would maybe say Brock, but much of his singularity comes from being such a physical/imposing presence and Kandori’s presence is obviously different, closer to the others mentioned. Regardless, all people I think quite highly of.  These obviously aren’t qualities that are unique to Kandori, but she brings them in a way and puts them in a package that I just don’t see another version of in wrestling. Her version of this wrestler is very distinct. Doing it in a time where most of her peers were working a different style (or one of a few other styles), Kandori stands out in the crowd to me and in turn, her matches stand out in a big way (more to come).  
 

Versatility

This is a pretty simple section. Kandori is a versatile performer and I mean that in sort of the most basic way imaginable. She has success in singles, tags, various gimmick, epic, compact, bloodly, and more light-hearteded matches.  While I have not done the week-to-week dive on (and I’m probably not doing that for anyone because it just isn’t how I watch wrestling), I can’t think of a scenario she was put in where she felt like she couldn’t excel.  Again, to circle this back to the top match section, she has a fairly diverse set of really top end matches. Even if you don’t love her work quite as much as I do, she pretty unquestionably has a varied set of highly praised matches that get noticed.

 

Psychology

I always find the idea of “psychology” a bit tricky. I have a sort of broad approach to psychology. To me, psychology is telling a story that achieves fidelity between all the moving parts (the participant, their relationship, the story, the promotion, etc) in a given context. There is wrestling psychology I like and wrestling psychology I don’t like, but it comes in many forms across time and space. Psychology also gets a little nuanced and layered as said fidelity is related to card placement, match timing, physical storytelling, playing off the audience, etc.  Kandori is really really good at psychology, maybe to a fault.  I can’t really think of a time where she didn’t work to achieve fidelity to her character and motivations. I can’t really think of a time she didn’t work to achieve fidelity to her relationship with her opponents or partners (though admittedly some of this may be lost on me watching with less context than when I watch… say… CM Punk matches, which I more organically followed in real time and understood in context). Additionally, I have spoken above about Kandori’s timing. I think she is also a very good physical storyteller, using moves to create a clear and salient narrative. Finally, take all I said about her singularity and just add that she uses it to really create drama and investment in a match.  I often find the home stretches of her matches insanely engaging for this reason.

This ties quite a few of the previous sections together as well. Kandori has excelled in a variety of match types and they are all held together through her commitment to who she is and what she does.  Again, this might be to a fault. Kandori might actually benefit a little bit if she gave a little more, but generally speaking I see this in the same vein as Hansen.  When Kandori gives and when Kandori goes to war with someone it means a great deal more. Leading me to……

 

Elevating Others

There are lots of ways wrestlers can elevate others, but one of the clearest ways is having another wrestler’s best match. I’m not going to spend much time on this because this one probably come down to my personal taste more than any other section because it comebines big match and style preference, but even if you don’t think Kandori has Bull’s, Hokuto’s, Devil’s, Inoue’s, Siato, and Hotta’s best singles matches and Aja’s best overall match in the form of that tag… which I do, she has matches that are in the conversation for a slew of joshi legends (those listed and quite a few others).  Let’s crosspollinate these sections again. Because of her singularity and commitment to her Kandoriness, she brings the best out of a lot of people. Getting the best of Kandori takes work and it feels like an accomplishment. Kandori is always bringing the urgency (one of my favorite qualities of a great match) and the violence and that often brings out the best in people. Granted a lot of those people are ultra talented, but I’m at least as interested (honest, more interested) in wrestlers who are able to help talented counterparts level up and create something that stands out in their great catalogues.

 

Doing Stuff in The Match: Offense and Selling

Back in 2017 on this thread OJ provided some pieces of a review in response to a question I had about people being previously low on Kandori.  In it was a line that I now always associate her now, "This allowed Kandori to be on offense most of the match, which she believes is her divine right anyway." Fuck yeah it is her divine right. Kandori’s offense is awesome. Honestly, she isn’t the tightest grappler or striker, but she is quite good at both and her intensity and urgency hold everything together. Her big spin puts all others to shame because she does it by someone’s fucking neck. Everything she does looks solid to great… but the important thing is it all looks like it hurts. She strikes a balance between execution and grit that I think is universally great, but was especially potent in 90s joshi. Even when there is a misfire she rarely lets anything sit long enough for it to matter.  Her selling is also quite good. She gives steadily that really allows her opponents to earn their ground, making everyone look better and everything matter more. As Dylan mentioned during the 2016 project, her long-term selling is also very good (another testament to her psychology). The long and short is that Kandori is good at the meat and potatoes of the match.

 

P.S. Longevity

I said I wasn’t going to make a real case for her longevity, and I won’t, but I’ll make a passing comment. I can’t speak to how much quality wrestling she has been producing in the last 10-12 years at this point, but she has been an active wrestler for 35 years. Even if – hypothetically – she has been the drizzling shits in the last 10 years and even if it was technically for MMA, that build with Gabi Garcia was as pro wrestling as it gets. Look up the photos of her in her full walk out robe at the presser. I think she even punched a picture of Gabi. Look at the mid ring pull apart she had with Gabi. That was top shelf pro wrestling. I didn’t want to see her fight Garcia in the least, but she had me biting on the hype. It is who she is in her soul, so I can’t imagine she wasn’t at least still FINE in the ring.

 

In conclusion, I want to reiterate, most wrestlers that are going to make my list (especially those who will place highly), are going to have some combination of the attributes above I listed.  Kandori isn’t unique in being great and having a well-rounded case. I’m not interested in lobbying for her to get top 10 votes (though it would warm my dark little dork heart). However, she belongs in that conversation in my mind, that elite conversation. She is probably going to be in my top 5-15 at the very lowest and I am going ahead and making my case for that here early and getting it out of the way. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 11 months later...

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
×
  • Create New...