Recently I've been doing a watch project for the year 2010, and in the middle of it I kind of lost the ambition to continue, but within in the past couple of days I picked it back up. Now on my spreadsheet I had an ongoing list of the best matches, but since it had been a while since I had watched them, I felt maybe it wasn't fair to compare them to the matches fresh on my mind. That led to me re-watching quite a few matches, but the one that stunned me was the one 5 star match I originally had for the year, Daniel Bryan vs. SHINGO from DGUSA. I remember absolutely loving the match, and even comparing it to Bryan vs. KENTA from ROH, but I wanted it to be fresh on my mind. Upon re-watching, it was a major let down, like I couldn't believe at one point I had the match as the best of the year. Not to say it's a bad match, but it certainly didn't hit the all-time classic mark I once had it at.
So this led to me wondering, has anyone else ever experienced such a fall of an opinion for a match? I understand knocking a match down a peg, (or 1/4th star if you use it), as I do it all the time, but I really want to know if anyone has really felt let down by a second or third watching of a match.